The Official Report is a written record of public meetings of the Parliament and committees.
All Official Reports of meetings in the Debating Chamber of the Scottish Parliament.
All Official Reports of public meetings of committees.
Displaying 454 contributions
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 February 2026
Tim Eagle
:I appreciate that. I guess that every complaint has to be taken on its merits, but it would be interesting to know whether the majority of complaints come from, say, local people who might have seen something whilst out walking their dog or whether most of them come from larger groups acting on behalf of a certain group, individuals working for a lobby group or whatever. However, you are not aware of that. When a complaint comes in, you do not look at that or analyse it in that way.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 February 2026
Tim Eagle
:I would agree. We do not live in a simple world, do we?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 February 2026
Tim Eagle
I see from our papers that Salmon Scotland has questioned why the committee has not looked more into anti-salmon farming campaign groups and what that means. When we talk about complaints and such, do you think that there are more vexatious complaints that are trying to close down the industry than there are perhaps genuine complaints—if that makes sense?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 February 2026
Tim Eagle
:I know that there is a complexity behind this, because we have had reports and various responses to consultations from certain groups arguing strongly against the salmon farming industry. It would just be interesting to know the sort of thing that I have been asking about, given some of the online media responses that we have seen over the last couple of years.
Ben, did you want to come in?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 25 February 2026
Tim Eagle
:Okay.
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Tim Eagle
I am just going to come in on that point, minister. That was my understanding. Legal experts have said that the legislation is quite patchwork and all over the place. Highland Council and Western Isles Council have commented that there should be a root-and-branch reform of crofting. I do not have the quote in front of me—I was desperately trying to find it—but I thought that the Scottish National Party had said that it would do a big reform of crofting law, and that is not what this bill is.
Within the consultation responses, there is wide acceptance that the bill contains some good stuff and we want to see that, but that does not take away from the fact that many, in the consultation responses and afterwards, including the Scottish Crofting Federation, have said that we need more of a root-and-branch reform of crofting law. Given that they have waited for years, how much longer do we need to wait to make sure that crofting is fit for the future?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Tim Eagle
Have you reflected on those differences, Mark? Imprisonment is not mentioned in the Welsh bill, but it is in yours. Have you reflected on whether you think that that is absolutely necessary?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Tim Eagle
If I am right, you just said that the Crofting Commission needs to know who is putting in complaints, but that is not the case. On 24 September, the representatives from the commission said to the committee that they would be “quite content” if anonymous reporting was allowed and
“it would not make any difference”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, 24 September 2025; c 21, 22.]
to their work. Why did they say that to us when you are saying something different?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Tim Eagle
I have a couple of questions, minister. The first is on carbon projects, because there is a valid point there. I did some work for a wind turbine on Scottish Government land—I probably should declare an interest in relation to that. A wind farm was going up, and we were giving crofters quite a significant amount of money. Then the crofting tenancies got the—[Interruption.]
I will let the minister cough. Feel free to get some water, minister. It is that time of year.
The big question, which has been got at a wee bit, is whether you are conscious that we do not want there to be speculative buying—or coming into—of land, such as deemed crofts or hill land, just because of the potential future value in the carbon markets, as that would ruin the whole ideology of what crofting is to the Highlands and Islands. Does that make sense?
Rural Affairs and Islands Committee [Draft]
Meeting date: 12 November 2025
Tim Eagle
I will come back quickly to deemed crofts. I am aware of an example on Jura, where one person has six deemed crofts but is considered absentee, and loads of other people in that area need, or would like, access to that ground but cannot get it. There have been a lot of questions today, but are you prepared to have discussions with us in advance of stages 2 and 3, to see whether more could be done in the bill around that issue?